"...the humans are up to something." (4/5)
My exposure to David Brin has been limited to five novels: the three Uplift series novels from Sundiver (1980), The Postman (1985), and Earth
(1990). So Earth is the most recent novel of Brin's which I've read and
given its twenty-two year age, Brin's style still resonates with me--a
style which is cleanly composed and indulgently intelligent. The 244,000
word novel is hefty in page count and even loftier in the
implementation of the imagination; each page blossoming with careful
thought, each idea stewed in applicable thought... the combination
invigorates the mind of the reader. With the keen eye of a science
fiction aficionado, there's even more thought behind the tome of
Existence than the plot and ideas, but there's also a slew of
backslapping towards the greats of science fiction (some subtle, some
blatant). The title of the review is a quote from the book (490-22) which gave me a chuckle and quite tidily summed up the entire novel.
Inside flap synopsis:
"Telepresence. Global
security. Everyone is watching everyone, all the time. Anything
interesting draws a flash crowd of ten million eyes. One man in
Afghanistan live-tweets a special forces attack, and the world tunes in.
Revolutions coordinate online. And that's today! Tomorrow, you'll wear
the Web, immersed in augmented overlays. Your aiware glasses will ID,
name-tage, and tattle on each person you walk by, in a global village of
ten billions souls.
"But instant access to all of human
knowledge only widens the gulf between those eager for tomorrow... and
those fearing an end to human existence.
"Gerald Livingston is an
orbital garbage collector, clearing a hundred-year mess, when we spots
something unexpected--a glinting crystal, unmapped and strange. An hour
after he captures it, rumors fill Earth's infomesh about an 'alien
artifact.'
"Peng Xiang Bin is a shoresteader off the Chinese
coast, salvaging homes abandoned to the rising tides. Under one mansion,
Bin finds a secret treasure cache. One box bears a warning: Inhabited
by demons.
"Tor Povlov is a new-era reporter, a genius at
trolling Web and street for exciting and heartbreaking 'you are there'
reports. On a cross-country zeppelin tour she documents an America and
world fracturing apart, torn between a future promising godlike powers
for all... and a beguiling past that might offer the only sanctuary. She
does not expect to find herself--and her million-member smart
posse--snagged by the biggest story ever.
"From a tribe of
beleaguered dolphins to the highest mountain observatory, Existence asks
the question: Are we alone in the universe? Does every bright new race
stumble over the same pitfalls? The same, entrapping seven hundred ways
to fail?
"Thrown into this maelstrom of worldwide shared
experience and tension over human destiny, the Artifact is a game
changer. A message in a bottle; an alien capsule that wants to
communicate... but for good or ill? The world reacts as humans always
do: with fear and hope and selfishness and love and violence. And
insatiable curiosity."
------------
With the book's own
synopsis covering nearly the entire plot, I have little more to add to
it. However, the book is awkwardly split into three notable time
periods:
(1) Parts 1-6 [pages 7-420] revolve around Earth's
reaction to the artifact found in Earth's orbit. There are actually two
crystal artifacts found and both tell different stories about their
history in the system, in the galaxy. Collaboration is needed to filter
the truth from the lies, a tricky process when dealing with alien
intelligences. There is open hostility towards the alien probe but there
is also open, progressive dialogue with it in an attempt to learn what
is needed. Unfortunately, the probe is unwilling to divulge any
technological information, an earlier promise which was conveyed through
the discoverer, Gerald Livingston. The personal message, however, does
not apply to everyone. Revelation after revelation, human begin to
understand the true nature of the probe.
(2) Part 7 [pages
421-508] shifts its timeframe tens of years after the discovery of the
probe. For want of limiting spoilers, I may simply add that the once
Earth-based plot shifts, like the timeframe, beyond the touch-base of
Earthly domain. It's an uncomfortable transition. The idea of the second
plot is wonderfully interesting but a little too action-packed, yet
feels artificially inserted into the flow of the entire novel. Brin
admits in the acknowledgments section that an earlier version of the
adventure in this section was previously published in the 1980s under
the title "Lungfish." So, there's little doubt why the first and second
section feel like stitch-up story!
(3) Part 8 [pages 509-553]
takes another leap into the future, yet another gap which leaves the
reader uncomfortable. Like section two, the third plot is wonderful in
its ideas of hard science and the importance to the greater plot. When
Brin states that "...the humans are up to something" (490-22), he really
goes all out with what humanity will possibly be capable in the future.
Where the aliens races found in the crystal were clever in their own
right, humanity finds that curiosity won't be the trait that kills them;
rather, it'll be the trait that propels them above the technological
plain above all other galactic races.
Studded throughout section
one, Brin prints excepts from a fictional books in the book's history,
the most notable is Pandora's Cornucopia, which reads like Brin's
fascination with all that could go wrong that leads to Earth's demise:
"...our means of self-destruction seem myriad" (13): "Surviving as a
technological civilization is like crossing a vast minefield [...] too
many mistakes and pitfalls lie in wait--bad trade-offs or ineludiable
paths of self-destruction" (345).
Besides Pandora's Cornucopia
highlighted between chapters, there are other tasty orts of perspective
from the "Toralyzer," quotes from Professor Noozone, news briefs,
dialogue from the Scanalyzer (à la Brunner's Stand on Zanzibar)
quotes from other fictional sources, and even quotes from modern
sources. These perspectives lighted upon the nuances of the plot are
more relevant that Brunner's Stand on Zanibar, which had a plethora of
data and snippets to overwhelm this reader. Brin's perspective additions
were pertinent to the greater picture he was trying to paint within.
In
the introduction, I mentioned the backslapping performed throughout the
novel towards science fiction greats (which I'll soon address), but
Brin also dips his metaphorical toes into the waters of modern thinkers
and morals: Ralph Nader's environmentalism, Adam Smith's moral
sentiments, anti-technological Luddism, and Ted Kaczynski's neo-Luddism.
Brin also refers to other scientists: Carl Sagan, Akimasa Nakamura, and
Allen Tough; other author's ideas: Brunner's Scanalyzer, Charles
Stross's Singularity Era, and Kim Stanley Robinson's shying away from
extremes; and modern references to Paul the Octopus of 2010 World Cup
fame (351-355) and cheeky nudge towards Charlton's Heston's role in
Planet of the Apes (1968).
The real geeky delight found in
Existence is when it comes to blatant and subtle references to other
science fiction authors and their respective works, some great, some
obscure. For the sake of science fiction history, I'll recognize the
novels below, but if this isn't your field of interest then you might as
well pass this section up:
Greg Bear's Slant (1998) [p. 64]
Isaac Asimov's I, Robot (1950) [p. 96]
Frederik's Pohl The Cool War (1981) [p. 142]
Niven & Pournelle's The Mote in God's Eye (1974) [p. 218, 489]
George Orwell's 1984 (1949) [p. 246]
Iain Banks' The Business (1999) [p. 284]
H.G. Wells' The Island of Doctor Moreau (1896) [p. 286]
Pierre Boulle's Monkey Planet (1963) [p. 286]
Cordwainer Smith's Norstrilia (1975) [p. 286]
John Brunner's Stand on Zanzibar (1968) [p. 401]
Isaac Asimov's Foundation (1951) [p. 431]
James Blish's They Shall Have Stars (1956) [p. 489]
Douglas Adam's Hitchhiker's Guide (1979) [p. 490]
One
most notable backslaps is with Iain Banks' The Business. In a Scanalyzer
sequence, a person using the pseudonym of Hagar describes a scene at
the Holy Kaaba which is beginning to glow because of the meteorite its
made from... the aliens begin to wake up to the fact that another crystal
has been found on Earth. This is the exact scenario which is found in a
fictional movie plot in The Business, which Jebbet Dessous outlines. A
small tribute to Banks... or just a coincidence?
------------
Even
including all the geek-dom wonderfulness and the opinion that each
section, in itself, is a great read, ultimately the three section don't
mesh together very well. I would have loved to have seen the first
section have a conclusion in its own timeframe, rather than having to
jump decades at a time to some far-flung conclusion. The first 420 pages
are captivating and rightly deserve five stars for the detail and
effort within, but the follow-up detachment is disappointing.
Existence could quite possibly be the best subjective SF novel of 2012, a close contender with Alastair Reynolds' Blue Remembered Earth and the future releases of Iain M. Banks' The Hydrogen Sonata (October 4, 2012) and Peter Hamilton's Great North Road
(September 27, 2012). Nothing this year has really astounded me, but
many parts of Existence surely had be pleasurably wallowing between the
viscous pages of Brin's tour de force.
No comments:
Post a Comment