Poor execution after a warmly ominous start (2/5)
From June 29, 2011
Having never read any Dickson before, I did a bit of research on him and
found that he's best described as a romanticized sci-fi writer, which
told me one thing: he sticks to sci-fi tradition. Being "romantic" is
just about the only adjective given to the man, so my initial hopes were
low. I know of his Dorsai series but it seems to be hard to find in these here parts. It's a must-buy for me but after reading Mission to Universe, I'm reluctant to pick up another Dickson novel of any sort: classic, relatively unknown, or short story collection.
Rear cover synopsis:
"General Benjamin Shore
was heading for the stars under forged orders - and in defiance of the
commands of the President. He was leaving Earth in an untested ship with
a crew chosen by necessity and with nothing but faith to guide him. His
only hope was to find habitable worlds in the unexplored reaches of
space ahead. Thus began Man's first mission to the uncharted universe. Shore
had no illusions. Before him lay danger, probable disappointment - even
death. But nothing had prepared him for the nightmare he would have to
face on the planet of the Gray-Furs... for the menace of the Golden
People who had driven all other races from Galactic Center--or for what
awaited him if he returned to the world he called home!"
The two chapters (of thirteen) of Mission to Universe are
ripe with potential: Benjamin Shore quietly assembles his crew in the
dead of the night, awaking their prone bodies to congregate in the
shift-ship. With presidential orders in hand denying the launch of the
ship to orbit, Benjamin alters the order and tells his crew to prepare
to embark to earth orbit, to Andromeda and beyond. The mainly narrative
text of the first two chapters has a creepy, ominous aura to it. It's a
sinister invitation not traditional in any sense.
Thereafter,
from chapters three to thirteen, we witness why Dickson has been
described as romantic: the ship's air recycler needs repair so they land
on a planet with tragic consequences, they land on another planet with
tragic consequences... and yet again, and again. It's almost as if
Dickson wrote the novel by stream-of-thought, himself thinking, "OK, now
that I've written them into this situation, how will I write them OUT
of it?" What follows is a ragtag attempt to snare the reader into the
adventure and danger of the shift-ship's journey to Andromeda.
Nothing
very clever ever surfaces from Mission to Universe. There are many dead
ends in the details, like the stowaway cat which plays no part through
the novel and only goes to characterize the female love interest as
girly and to draw her closer to Benjamin (I had other grander ideas of
why the cat was on the ship). When the ship discovers life on two
planets, I could quickly draw conclusions as to the state of their
civilizations. Dickson may have written Benjamin as a quick thinker, but
he never saw me coming.
(And you can't put yourself into orbit
around a planet without having any velocity. The shift-ship only shifts
and has no means to physically propel itself. Dumb point, but still.)
All
in all, it may have been written for the YA age bracket. When the rear
cover synopsis reads "A riveting space adventure," that kind of language
gives it away. BUT, like I said about the first two chapters, there is
potential in Dickson and I've already bought a short story collection In the Bone and another lengthier novel entitled The Forever Man. I won't whitewash Dickson with criticism yet, but he already has negative marks in my book.
No comments:
Post a Comment